"Brett's large-scale art ... showcases the Maine spring in full bloom and offers close-up images of cats that feline lovers will savor."
– Publishers Weekly
"Sandy Fuller's fifth book is a charming story told in rhyming verse about a little girl and a Maine coon cat becoming friends. With her gentle verses and illustrated by Jeannie Brett (who has done several other Maine books), this is a quiet, peaceful story, perfect for bedtime reading."
–Bill Bushnell, The Kennebec Journal
"The artwork is expressive yet simple. Highly detailed from the little girl's eyelashes to the patterns on the cat fur... gorgeous to look at. The story is simple, sweet, with a gentle rhyme."
– Amy Henry, The Black Sheep Dances
"The book is full of delightfully detailed watercolors that are painted with a bright, eye-catching color palette. the beautifully captured nature scenes (birch trees, bright purple flowers, tree blossoms) and the lovely depictions of inside a home (rugs, toys, wallpaper) are engaging and invite the readers to linger over each page... the simple, lyrical verse that flows from page to page will make you smile. It is an easy-to-follow, heartwarming storyline that will win the hearts of parents and children alike."
– The Old Schoolhouse Magazine
"The new book is a wonderful children's book written in rhyming verse by Sandy Ferguson Fuller. It tells the story of a flip flop-wearing young girl slowly befriending an elusive Maine coon cat. This book features Brett's beautiful lifelike illustrations of nature."
– Amy Johnson, York Weekly
"If you have children or grandchildren, you'll want to check out My Cat, Coon Cat ... It's a sweet tale (tail?) about a young girl, her little kitten, and a big Maine Coon cat who welcomes them to a new home. Set in Maine, the illustrations immediately brought the sights, sounds, and smells of a Maine summer to my mind. I could almost smell the pine trees and hear the crickets. This is a book for an early reader, and also a book to sit down and read together. ... Even the youngest child will enjoy the story, the illustrations, and the rhyme."
– Maine Coon Cat Nation
“The illustrations are full of color and character, capturing with equal charm the bucolic background and the winsome feline…The intimate nature of the quiet communication between the girl and the feline lends itself best to sharing one-on-one, although the spreads would show up well in a group setting. Any reader who has ever known the love of a cat will find much to relate to in this cozy book.” —School Library Journal